The Garden Helper

Helping Gardeners Grow Their Dreams since 1997.

No-dash-here, you've found The Real Garden Helper! Gardening on the Web since 1997

Please help me with my Peace Lily!!!!

Gardening Reference » Gardening in 2005
by Smh023 on June 22, 2005 11:40 PM
I need some help with one of my peace lilies. I have three and two of them they are doing very well I have had two of them for about two years.
Well I recently got this one about 2 months ago and I had to repot it bc I bought it at Home Depot and you know they have really crappy pots that they come in.
So I was watering it once a week (like I do my other ones) and it started to bud a new leaf and then all the other leaves just went down. It looks so pitiful. I don’t know what to do! Then I was thinking it wasn’t getting enough sun so I moved it closer to the window and it still looks the same. Then I thought I was watering it too much (but I didn’t see how when I was only watering it once a week) and as of now I haven’t watered it in about 5 days and it still looks the same. HELP I don’t want it to die!!!!!!!!!!!!

This is one I have had for 2 years.
My 2nd one that I have had for 2 years.

This is the one that needs help............
What it looked like when I bought it!
What it looks like now!!!!!
by phoenix on June 23, 2005 12:13 AM
[wayey] smh023
i'm wondering what the roots looked like when you repotted it. did you happen to look at them? i purchased a couple of plants from home depot and the roots were rotten. i'm not saying that is the case with yours but it's worth a shot. with places like home depot and the like you tend to take a chance on the "condition" the plant is actually in. i learned the hard way [tears]
you may want to take it out of the dirt and check the roots. hope i was of some help [Wink]

* * * *
"If you want to talk bollocks and discuss the meaning of life,you're better off downing a bottle of whiskey.That way you're drunk by the time you start to take yourself seriously"
by Smh023 on June 23, 2005 12:26 AM
Thanks Phoenix, I honestly can't remember what they look like?
But would a new leaf be budding out like it is if the roots where rotten?
by Will Creed on June 23, 2005 05:53 AM
The problem is related to the repotting.

What kind of soil did you use?

Did you remove a lot of the soil it came in?

Are there drainage holes in the bottom of the new pot?

How dry does the soil feel after a week of no water?
by Smh023 on June 28, 2005 08:27 PM
What kind of soil did you use? ~ I use miracle grow.

Did you remove a lot of the soil it came in? ~ Not too much just enough to get the roots free so it can grow in the new pot.

Are there drainage holes in the bottom of the new pot? ~ There are rocks at the bottom of the pot.

How dry does the soil feel after a week of no water? ~ It feels a little dry but a little damp if that makes any sense the dirt isnt dry and flaky but it isnt soaking wet either.
by Smh023 on June 28, 2005 08:29 PM

by Will Creed on June 29, 2005 08:04 AM
The roots are rotting. The culprit is the lack of drainage holes. Rocks or other drainage material in the bottom of the pot is an old-fashioned notion that has been discredited as a helpful horticultural practice.

Not only does the excess water have no place to drain out, but neither do the gases that build up around the roots. No drainage holes is a particularly deadly combination with plants like peace lilies that stay in evenly moist soil.

You can unpot and try salvaging it, but my guess is that there are few if any healthy roots remaining. If there are, put the slimmed down rootball into a small pot that has drainage holes.

Wish I had better news, but it is good learning experience about potting.
by Smh023 on June 29, 2005 08:35 PM
Well my first peace lily pictured is in a pot with nothing? No rocks or drainage holes and it has been doing great for 2 yrs??
My second peace lily has a drainage hole but I saved that one from my work and I havent repotted it.

That is why I dont understand why this one is dying? I just did it like I have always done my other plants.

But I will try to save it, I feel sad that it is dying. [Frown]
by Will Creed on June 30, 2005 05:43 AM
I can't say for sure why there is a difference. However, the soil and your watering of the two plants is not identical. It is possible to maintain a plant in a drainless pot, but it is very dicey and, more often than not, results in eventual root deterioration.

by Smh023 on July 01, 2005 08:39 PM
Well I had to lay my poor peace lily to rest last night. It was true the roots were dead. [tears] [tears]
Even the base of the stalk where the leaves started to come out was black. [tears]
Well I just assumed that since my other plants were doing fine in a non drainage pot then that one would too.
BUT I do have a rubber plant and two palms in a non drainage pot and they are doing fine.

Does it depend on some plants how well they do or not? Or should all plants really need to be in a drainage pot?
by Will Creed on July 03, 2005 09:06 AM
I am sorry, but not surprised, about your peace lily.

Using pots without drainage holes is a risky venture with any potted plant. It is more risky with plants that need to dry out often, such as succulents.

The problem is that the damage done by the slow accumulation of water and gases in the bottom of drainless pots is very slow and hidden from view. By the time it becomes apparent, it is usually too late.

Active Garden Forum

Search The Garden Helper: